I didn't get the impression that either dani's post or lomapaseo's were referring directly to you or your posts. In dani's case he wasn't at all swatting at flies; he was making (what I thought at least) was an accurate and appropriate comment re some of the speculation of the past day.
Grizzled, Dani seemed to be pretty explicitly stating that he believed that the VS had separated in flight:
Those fins depart from the fuselage (for whatever reason) and "fly" like a feather earthwards. That's why they don't get destroyed on impact.
I think that was part of what PJ2 was getting at.
FBW