PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - AF447
Thread: AF447
View Single Post
Old 8th June 2009 | 22:29
  #726 (permalink)  
PJ2
20 Anniversary
 
Joined: Mar 2003
: ATPL
Posts: 2,558
Likes: 155
From: BC
ManaAdaSystem;
Why would they be pumping the rudder to it's max during turbulence?
Where on earth are you getting that from?!

There is certainly no evidence nor even a suggestion that "pumping" the rudder was done. Stick to what is available.

(Why do I post here at all for heaven's sake?....).

Dani - there is NO suggestion nor should there be, as to how/when/why the vert stab came off. It is off and that is the only evidence we have before us. Your swatting at flies that don't exist.

lomapaseo;

I believe we agree here. There is no "eureka" suggested of course. I state my intent very clearly and warn that drawing conclusions cannot be done. I am trying to contribute to knowledge by examing "what is" and nothing more - we simply cannot do more without allowing imagination to take over from facts.


I have to say in general, that there is once again, great hazard in posting any suggestion or comment with reference to anything new coming in. At the slightest suggestion some ride off in all directions setting their hair on fire about all and unrelated sundry over new comments. Let's stick to what is known, which is extremely little. To give life to theories only serves interests which may not have the same goals in mind...
PJ2 is offline