We all survived just fine for decades before these requirements were introduced with absolutely no more fatalities or accidents.
Flybymike
I agree with you up to a point. A responsible pilot will ensure that he flies safely and thoroughly briefs him or herself before flying, especially if there has been a lapse of some months. One doesn't loose handling skills that quickly. It's more a case of remembering all the drills.
On the other hand, flying with an instructor from time to time is not a bad idea (even if they also get lost sometimes - sorry maggie
).