Atlantic Cowboy,
I have a copy of the video. It clearly shows that you can see the breakers on the Mull coast and that the cloud cover did not go as low or as far out from the coast as the MoD says it does.
I have also read the statements from those on the Mull and you are right, they were stood in cloud. What none of them can say is what the view was like when looking towards the Mull.
Insults add nothing to the debate.
Chinook 240,
you say that "They were the facts at the time of the BoI". That may well be so, but since that time more information has become available that, perhaps, was not available at the time of the BoI. That does not invalidate the work that they did, but it certainly makes their finding unsustainable.
My best, as always,
Brian
"Justice has no expiry date" - John Cook