I think it is a little excessive - no injuries to anybody, another qualified pilot on the flight deck who can take over if there was any doubt etc, no malicious intent
This job is disintegrating as a career right in front of us - deteriorating T&C's, extra security hassle, huge investment at the start, bust at a moments notice. Not worth the hassle any more
Look at the destruction Fred Goodwin has done to us all, and he gets away with it