What happens in year 3 is whatever you negotiate. You're coming at this like cabin crew are the only ones affected by these proposed cuts and everyone else gets a "thanks very much, here's your cash back" in year 3. That's not on the table for anyone. I don't disagree with you that the company are trying to take advantage of the circumstances, but I do disagree with the "Why are they only after cabin crew?" propaganda being spread by certain parties who've long been resistant to any change due to their zero-sum mentality.