Hi Horror Box,
I see nothing in Malabo's post that sounds like "Condemnation", (I presume you are alluding to condemnation of the crew) the sequence of events he describes could be caused by many things outwith the crews control such as FDCs AHRS type instrument and display failures that would produce a similar result.
When the is so little "Factual" information to be used other than the graphic account that the dammaged aircraft provides itself in the pictures and the stony silence from the Powers that Be people will speculate.
Happily nobody was really injured in the incident so I think we do have some freedom of expression without finger pointing.
I think we call all agree that the tail did not fall off in flight as the result would have been very very different as the CG goes for a ball of chalk and the yaw rate would have torn the AC apart on contact with the water......
We could all be AAIB Investigators if we try hard enough!!!