FFF
Your quote
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Based on the outcome of previous threads on this subject, I've always logged any dual time with an instructor as P/UT. I was always reasonably sure this was correct, but never 100%. Now, though, I'm much less sure that this is correct - but it's what I'll continue to do, for the reasons I've stated above.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am also not 100% sure what is correct, but having read the thread this far and taken guidance from my ATPL/FIC rated spouse, as well as a member of the SRG of the CAA, I am going to record dual time on check rides with an Instructor as P1 U/S.
My understanding is that whatever GID44 says, the CAA do not mind pilot licence holders recording check rides with an Instructor as P1 U/S provided the Instructor endorses your logbook and did not actually give 'instruction for the purposes of awarding a licence or rating', or have to intervene during the flight in the interests of safety.
I you were doing a checkride with someone who is not an Instructor on a group owned aircraft or similar for familiarisation purposes, I presume it would be logged as P1?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Confused? You will be!