PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Palm OS - v - Win2002ce OS
View Single Post
Old 4th April 2002 | 05:51
  #4 (permalink)  
Feline
 
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 175
Likes: 0
From: Deepest Dark Afrika
Palm works for me!

By and large, I agree with BA London. Am not hugely familiar with latest version of Win CE, but experiences with earlier versions were not too happy - applications which run reasonably well on a larger platform don't necessarily scale down to a pocket size platform too comfortably, and successful synchronisation between the portable device and desktop was a finicky and somewhat frustrating experience.
The PPC is really being aimed at the corporate market where in-house applications an be extended down to an ultra-portable device and deployed to (for example) a sales force.
In my opinion, Palm still has the edge. The built in apps are elegant, clean, and don't consume enormous resources. In addition, there are literally thousands of applications available for the Palm (almost too many - choosing the best app for one's particular needs can be tedious).
With the addition of a keyboard and a couple of third party applications, I now leave my laptop behind and travel only with my Palm without any significant loss in functionality or effectiveness. I use WordSmith to cater for my word processing needs (it install a button in MS Word on my desktop system and simply clicking on the button means that the Word document I am working on will be transferred to my Palm during the next HotSync). Eudora Internet Suite provides me with e-mail via an IR link to my cell phone - it also provides a web browser by means of which I have browsed PPRuNe from unlikely places - although web browsing from such a small screen over such a slow link is not recommended as a particular relaxing experience ... Other third party apps I use are Natara's Bonsai (an outliner that I use for project management), AvantGo (downloads news feeds), and funSMS (brings some order to my Text Messaging).
Because of the less efficient use of resources (mainly memory but screen size to a lesser extent), WinCE devices will usually be more expensive in the first place, and battery life will be hugely less than a Palm device (typical effective battery life on most WinCe devices is measured in hours whereas Palm devices measure it in days). As a simple rule of thumb, 8Mb on a Palm equates to about 64Mb on a WinCE device
Finally, I cannot emphasise too much the effectiveness of the Palm's HotSync - drop it on its cradle and press the button, and the handheld and desktop are synchronised - no if's, buts or maybe's ... As they say -- Works for me!

Hope that helps ...
Feline is offline