PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Spanair accident at Madrid
View Single Post
Old 23rd Aug 2008, 10:10
  #641 (permalink)  
Kyunghee
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Exeter
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
There appear to be mixed messages coming from Spanair and the head of civil aviation in Spain regarding the air temperature gauge.

This is from Associated Press and appears in several newspapers.

Police and investigators probing the deadly plane crash in Madrid have questioned the mechanic who cleared the plane for takeoff after tending to a minor mechanical problem, the airline said Saturday. Spanair said the mechanic dealt with a problem in an air temperature gauge that forced the pilot to abandon a first attempt to take off. About an hour later, when the MD-82 finally did take off, it crashed near the end of the runway, burning and largely disintegrating. A total of 153 of the 172 people aboard were killed.
The newspaper El Pais quoted unnamed sources close to the investigation as saying that during two sessions of testimony Friday - first with police and then with crash investigators - the mechanic insisted that the gauge malfunction was a minor glitch which had nothing to do with Wednesday's crash.
A Spanair official told The Associated Press on Saturday it had no details of the man's testimony, but reiterated that the mechanical problem did not cause the crash. The official spoke on condition of anonymity, citing company rules.
Aviation experts have told The AP this problem probably did not cause the crash.
All 19 survivors of the crash remained hospitalized Saturday, two of them in critical condition. The worst off was a 31-year-old woman with burns to 72 percent of her body. Her husband died in the crash but her six-year-old son survived.
Only 50 bodies have been identified so far. Many were burned beyond recognition and forensic teams have been using DNA techniques for identification.

Spanair said the mechanic dealt with the gauge problem by essentially turning the device off, and said this was an accepted procedure because the gauge was not an absolutely essential piece of equipment.
But the head of Spanish civil aviation, Manuel Bautista, told the AP in an interview Friday that the gauge should be closely examined to see if it did contribute to the accident.
Bautista said a combination of failures likely caused the disaster.
''A problem with a temperature sensor may not matter at all, or it can be very important, depending on what other circumstances accompany it,'' Bautista said. ''We will have to see what other issues were present.''
This can be no comfort to the greiving relatives who are seeking early answers.
Kyunghee is offline