PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Spanair accident at Madrid
View Single Post
Old 20th Aug 2008, 20:33
  #169 (permalink)  
BeechNut
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Canada
Posts: 257
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
No, it ranks as third deadliest, if the reported numbers are valid...

1. Inex Adria Aviopromet, 1981, 180 fatalities.
2. West Caribbean Airways, 2005, 160 fatalities.
3. Spanair, 2008, 140+ fatalities.
That would in fact make it the 4th deadliest (a bit ghoulish I know, this sort of "contest").

Third would be Northwest 255, Detroit, 1987, 154 fatalities on board, 2 on the ground. Cause of accident was failure of the crew to set flaps/slats for takeoff, and a few other holes in the swiss cheese that lined up to get them there.

That said, I was quite taken aback by this headline:

"Accident History Of MD-80 Series: The MD-82 plane that crashed in Madrid is part of an aircraft series that has a history blighted with accidents. "

from Sky News

I guess it wouldn't do for a reporter to actually look up the facts before sensationalizing...

Fatal event rate per million flights:

Boeing (!) MD80/90 0.24
CRJ 0.24
737 all models 0.37
737NG 0.14
A320 series 0.15
737-300/400/500 (contemporary to the MD80) 0.20
Fokker 70/100 0.46
757 0.32
767 0.41
747 0.79

As at the end of 2006; I doubt the stats have changed radically since then.

just to give a random pick. The MD80 series thus compares well with its contemporaries. Source: Airsafe.com

Beech
BeechNut is offline