Mmmmmm ....
"Ok, guy no2 has been fired from his last 4 companies for one thing or another, unreliable over the last few years etc"
Perhaps you added this little sentence to try to justify your frustrations (and your arguement).
What if you said ......
"Ok Guy No2 had been fired from his last company because he objected to doing a job
his experience told him was tasked unsafely ...."
Guy No1 ...not experienced enough to realise where the traps are ????
What then!
AND .... I also agree with Troggy ...... again!