The following is a general observation and NOT personal!!
When asking for comparisons, always bear in mind that the person giving the view will base that on their own personal upbringing, cultural heritage/expectations, age, gender, travelling experience (predominantly biz/holiday) and even how long since they last had a good/bad experience with that/those carriers.
One of the things we often hear is that carriers can be crew and base dependent, giving a different experience from different starting points.