I have lost the will to live. This one has come up again quicker than usual......
God knows why we keep on debating this subject.
There are 2 main camps on this. The camp that says you are always PUT, usually the Instructors who want the P1 time (despite many protestations otherwise) and the renters who are current and legal and entitled to P1.
Until the CAA actually make a clear cut statement it will never be settled and I don't see one coming anytime soon!!