Hi Hamish,
I'm sorry but I don't think it will. P1S is only for the successful completion of a skills test and not club checkouts. Your instructor can't log P1 and instruct you to log P1S. Unless she logged SNY, in which case you can log P1, you have to log PUT. Although you perhaps weren't strictly "under training" there is no other legal option.
Unfortunately like me you have been told to log these hours under a classification which isn't legal. Again I understand that we are all ultimately responsible for what we log but in my opinion this is more evidence that the classification of P1S isn't widely understood by some flying clubs and instructors who may be misleading students.
Last edited by Eurotraveller; 8th May 2008 at 12:19.