pilotbear:
Why people should feel it necessary to criticise someone else's reasoning is beyond me, Oh wait, we are on pprune! any excuse for loud mouth 'holier than thou' thought police to get their word in and dictate the way things should be done.
but...
pilotbear:
Especially the cowardly anonymous ones
which part is your last name? "Bear"?
...relax, I'm joking! would you want everybody to leave his phonenumber?
But also I know what you're coming from, people feel brave when their name isn't public.
pace:
My concern is that there isnt enough left of the wreckage to 100% determine a cause and only the pilots might know when the plot was lost.
my point exactly! (so there will be no real result of the investigation)
Guesswork here isnt going to add anything as we all try to imagine scenarios where such a situation may occur.
If its valid and professional "guesswork" I don't see a problem with it!?
So because there's nothing left, we all should shut up, mind our own business and (besides condolences) never discuss what might have led to the accident?
People who have known a person involved might not like the outcome or the discussion itself, which is understandeable, but maybe "they" should not take a personal offense (I stress: from a professional discussion).
Only my two cents
(and unfortunately nothing that has really to do with the topic)