Yes Fatal...it is easy to write on this forum accusing others...as in the past I invite you to present your facts in the office so my errors and/or incapacity can be brought to light...some statements from the first officers who were involved in taking control of the aircraft would be most welcome, as a review of the appropriate QAR tapes can bring all the details to light. If you are really who and what you claim to be, then safety would be your primary concern, and proper action must be taken, not hiding behind your name on Pprune and making unsupported statements.