You likes what you knows.........
Did ab-initio on both PA-28s and C152s. Warrior was a great all-rounder, lots of space and with 180hp (Cherokee 180) a very useful tourer. The only one I would avoid was the old Cherokee 140 which was effectively a 2-seater and with the Hershey bar wing could fall out of the sky at slow speed on a very hot day. C152 very delicate and great fun, but more suited to solo esp low XC flight. Tried a C152Aerobat out in Florida which was the best aerobatic fun this side of a Chipmunk.
Best all rounder???? Probably a Warrior 160..... or C172.