Good point fernytickles, the private pilot forum is not the place for squabbling about who has done what and whos sand box is bigger.
So I shall apoligize to SNS3Guppy for being confrontational and shall refrain from getting into personal opinions regarding the difference between " Real " engine failures and other types of engine problems....
.....for sure it is possible to give the wrong message to new pilots and I don't want to do that.
And the time has long passed since I have a desire to measure dick size with other pilots anyhow.