I did my PPL on a 152 then 172, then moved to the PA28 for my IMC. I like both the 172 and Warrior for different reasons:
172 = short field capabilities and two doors (feels like it might be quicker to get out of)
PA28 = I prefer the vis, and like you say, it feels like a 'real' plane..to me it seems a little more responsive. Great to fly.
I now have a share in a PA28 and, short-field capability aside, have no regrets.
You'll get used to the hand-brake, the fuel pump and the throttle very quickly.