clearfinalsno1
Instead of Tiree/Islay go midway and try the Colonsay Hotel (if your aeroplane can manage the 500m strip). A few years ago it was excellent, although it's since changed hands I believe.
Go and report back to us all!
(I know the original posters wanted the thread kept positive but the strip on Colonsay has such adverse camber at the eastern end that it caused the only near-groundloop I've suffered in over 200hr of tailwheel flying - won't stop me going back though
)
PS agree with Scottish182 - the Machrie hotel on Islay (the golf club) is pretty good too. Perhaps the best beefburger I've ever tasted - think they claim to use local produce.