Well I wasn't going to get invloved in this one...
...but the John Marsh showed up.
Mr.Marsh, I fully agree with all points observed by others against your report, but I would like to further add that this is a forum for professional pilots to communicate professional matters with each other. We tolerate SLF, indeed welcome it at times (although, frankly, not too often), but we do not want to start being affraid to discuss certain things for fear of it being reported to some authority by someone who is outside of the industry - someone who had no appreciation of how things are handled or indeed what exactly the technical nature of the problem is. Sorry if I offend you.
Please, please, all you SLF, stop spoiling it for all of us!