Correct me if I'm wrong, but this is the Professional Pilots' Rumour Network isn't it? Pablo is a professional pilot and although he may have made an error of judgement, we're supposed to support each other - why else do we have a discussion forum? I learned to be opme and honest in my debriefs, but slagging each other off is mere tittle-tattle, unless the rest of you are perfect pilots, and I haven't flown with one of them yet, but I have flown with some really dull ones who didn't have the capacity to do anything remotely exciting. Perhaps Pablo just need some support from the people who trained to do the same job he did.