One for the twin drivers ...

[rustle]

Originally Posted by stickandrudderman

Remember: there's no such thing as a good or a bad decision, there's just decisions.
However, NOT MAKING ONE AT ALL IS BAD!

What bizarre parallel universe do you occupy where there are no good or bad decisions?

Shutting down the wrong engine sounds like an inexcusably bad decision;

Overflying instead of landing at a suitable airfield when engine-out sounds like a bad decision in a light twin;

Leaving the PIC to decide whether any situation is a "mayday" or "PAN" (rather than decide it in advance here) sounds like a good decision