This thread has run to 55 pages so far, as ever on pprune there has been some lively debate as people have expressed their opinions. Most of the contributors are well known and have established their credibility one way or the other.
Then there are those who join just to post on this thread, to offer their opinion, well they are free to do that. But please, don't just come on here with a few reminiscences of the Nimrod being designed for para dropping blah blah etc whilst at the same time displaying a startling ignorance of MoD policies, procedures and standards etc.
Have a read through the thread, all 55 pages of it, read some of the other threads on similar subjects, try and get an understanding of what people are discussing. Then, when you've done that, come back and tell us if you still feel the same way, and tell us if you think people should just stay silent when they know that things are inadequate, wrong or involve significantly greater risk than is necessary.