Originally Posted by punkalouver
[...] I was asked basically what I would do in this situation. Or maybe the captain listened to a couple of guys on an web site somewhere questioning the prudence of following an RA.
We already knew that you would always follow an RA.
You were asked to show the error in the argument that the Baskirian crew's actions were rational, and how you arrived at your conclusion that it was not rational.
Bernd