We have already been through this. Please read or re-read post #50 from myself.
I find it amazing that a specialist on aircraft safety is telling us that if we end up in a similar scenerio as the one over Germany that night that we should ignore the RA and in fact go against it.
Please read more about sometimes trying to out-think the TCAS as you advocate.
http://www.asasi.org/papers/2005/Hir...in%20Japan.pdf