I think if he had stuck to a better phrased and coherent question minus all the other rambling nonsense he might have been taken more seriously. His second post didn't do much to improve his already dented image either.
One thing I know from my own air-to-air experiences is that the minimum safe and legal seperation can look shockingly close to one who doesn't know better. It can look even worse if you're in a turn. Alcohol may also play tricks with what you think you saw.
I think that a more sensible posting may have invited some equally more sensible replies.