PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - HMS Daring eases through first sea trials
Old 22nd Aug 2007, 11:21
  #100 (permalink)  
DarkBlueLoggie
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: UK
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Quote:
I wonder why they chose Phalanx instead of Goalkeeper? Topweight / Space / Deck penetration issues?
Reckon you're right with the space/deck penetration issues...relatively speaking, you can plonk a Phalanx almost anywhere on deck it'll physically fit and have a clear view from. Goalkeeper is a much heavier system which requires significantly more under-deck space (its ammo is stored and loaded from below, whilst phalanx has a drum mounted on the gun itself).

Goalkeeper also costs a lot more .....but seems to me the better solution, though if it just won't fit, then it just won't fit.....
Probably issues with topweight - they've had to make the ship awfully beamy to take that tall mast. Goalkeeper (30mm) is a much better, heavier, system, but as WolvoWill says, Phalanx (20mm) can be put virtually anywhere, you just need a power feed. Goalkeeper needs below deck space, water and power feeds etc. A lot more expensive too - only 2 of the 3 CVSs were ever fitted with Goalkeeper (which we got in exchange for some RR Gas Turbines from the Netherlands).
DarkBlueLoggie is offline