Since Basair do train many students, it is unfair to take the circumstances of "a select few" as the standard coming from the college.
If some of the above employers have come accross students who lack CPL qualities, then i suspect it is the student who is at fault and not the college.
The instructors and staff there can only do so much to help students become good pilots, so i hardly see it fair to dump the blame on a company, especially when in order to pass the CPL stage, they have to have reached the required outcomes, if not, then i know who this thread should really be about.