Beagle.
I'm not sure you're completely right in your contention that a CPL or higher licence subsumes a PPL. Ancient aviator that I am, I have one of those old 'forever' PPLs as well as my ATPL and I understand that I can still utilise that PPL, should I so choose (though, for the life of me I can't see why I'd want to!). This came out in my most recent Instructor Seminar.