PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - TAM A320 crash at Congonhas, Brazil
View Single Post
Old 23rd Jul 2007, 21:59
  #426 (permalink)  
EFHF
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Helsinki
Age: 47
Posts: 43
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Originally Posted by BOAC
armchairpilot - a quick skim through a long report there - is there anything relevant in it? I could not see any 'conclusions' on a quick look.
I think the "relevant" part is that it was another A320 overrun in -RA conditions with reverser #2 INOP and that ended up to the left from the runway end. The difference is that no casualties, basically because the runway and stopway were 2765 m long.

The report linked by amrchairpilot was a "Factual Data Report", so no conclusions there. The main causes to the Taipei accident are in the final report as follows:
Originally Posted by Aviation Safety Council of Taiwan
3.1 Findings Related to Probable Causes
1. When the aircraft was below 20 ft RA and Retard warnings were sounded,
the pilot flying didn’t pull thrust lever 2 to Idle detent which caused the
ground spoilers were not deployed after touchdown though they were at
Armed position, therefore the auto braking system was not triggered.

Moreover, when the auto thrust was changed to manual operation mode
automatically after touchdown, the thrust lever 2 was remained at 22.5
degrees which caused the Engine 2 still had an larger thrust output
(EPR1.08) than idle position’s. Thereupon, the aircraft was not able to
complete deceleration within the residual length of the runway
, and
deviated from the runway before came to a full stop, even though the
manual braking was actuated by the pilot 13 seconds after touchdown.
(1.11.2、2.3.2、2.3.3、2.4)
2. The pilot monitoring announced “spoiler” automatically when the aircraft
touched down without checking the ECAM display first according to SOP
before made the announcement, as such the retraction of ground spoilers
was ignored
. (2.3.3)
EFHF is offline