This is all very subjective isn't it. Some could argue that this thread should be moved to the "sin bin"; others argue that this is a valid "need to be discussed" point - who decides where this line in the sand is? I can think of only a few emotive issues where everyone agrees the same way (kiddy porn for example); what's good for the goose may not be so for the gander.
And who do you all propose as the moderator?; I think you will find all the upstanding PPRuNe individuals work full time?