Interested,
Sorry that I "trouble" you - however, reading through the entire thread, I'm delighted to note that it isn't just me that causes you alarm. It's everyone else too. You see, I don't think there is anyone that could assure the rest of us that after 50 hours on a 152, they could perform well in said situation.
You seem to doubt what I say in my post. I don't know why. Yes, my e-mail address contains the name Cessna, when I'm rated on a Piper. Wow! As it happens, I created the address specifically for when I was away in Scotland, having been sponsored by the RAF through 20 hours of C152 training. All my subsequent training has been in the PA-28. All of which is utterly irrelevant anyway, as the situation does not change a jot.
If the thought of being in Melanie's situation doesn't strike some kind of emotion into you, then I suggest it is YOU that has the problem.
Maybe you need to open up a little?
(Check 6, e-mail sent. Many thanks).