I don't disagree with you PB.
There's good and bad stuff that happened. Depending on where you put the emphasis of your report, or opinion, reflects on how the crew's performance looks.
And no, I haven't flown an ILS where things don't look right. Mainly because we don't have those high tech approaches around this part of Aus and so I do very very few of them. I have to make do with those dodgy NDB thingos and if I'm lucky, a VOR. So I'm not really overly qualified to comment on the specifics of what happened.