Whirly - Thanks. Very kind of you to step in there. I obviously was commenting about the second post, not yours PB. The AAIB can presumably do their investigations from a photo in the newspaper now.
This is not an anti-Robinson thread. This is a general point (that has now been raised by others) that we cannot and should not apportion blame so easily.
If CF ever has the misfortune of being involved in an accident, I hope his "peers" are not so quick to claim pilot error without a full investigation. If somebody had been injured or worse, would he be so quick to post?
We know these posts are read by non-aviation types including press and families. Do we need to be so quick to point the finger, even if you may turn out (after a long investigation by the real experts) to be correct?