ATC Watcher - I can't see much wrong with the TCAS comments (apart from not understanding Alexbans compatibility statement).
If you are suggesting that TCAS should be obeyed in every situation (even quiet airspace with an extreme manoeuvre by one a/c whilst the other is close to coffin corner) then you need to read the posts again.
Airmanship comes from looking at the whole picture.100% reliance on automation with flawed logic and lateral capability issues (in the circumstances detailed above) is inappropriate.