The problem with the phraseology is that it is the opposite order to what is in the Mats Pt 1. How can you be told off, or tell someone off, for using phraseology that's written in the Mats Pt 1?
I tried a conditional with the new phraseology (at a v quiet time), and while I said:
"C/s, after the landing a/c, via A1, line up and wait Rw xx"
It sounded like I said:
"C/s, after the landing A/c via A1, line up and wait Rw xx"
The irony is, that when the A/c is at A1, there is absolutely no way that it can enter the runway via any other point...! (And we're not allowed intermediate departures anyway)
Sonic