In fact the chap that took adice from the CAA and listed it as below is incorrect
That chap would be me, and I think that if you read my post at the top of the page you will see that I do not believe the advice I was given in 2001from the CAA to be entirely correct, I posted it as an example of The CAA not being clear to everyone about this subject. I think most here will understand that P1 = PIC, and that /us = /s (argue about that without me!). Therefore 1 & 2 are correct, but 3 & 4 are, to say the least, ambiguous. This sums it up very well I think
The CAA's wishy-washy statements on this help no-one.
Please follow the link and read the thread from 2001.
Regards, SD..