Found the article, it's here
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article...7-2340502.html
Must admit, on 2nd reading, it does appear a little wishy washy, although a little frightening that their own Royal College, is being so critical.
There are some surgeons who have a seriously flawed opinion of their own capabilities,” he said. “If you are a surgeon and doing dangerous work you need to have a degree of self-assurance and confidence but it can turn into arrogance.
Does a appear a little subjective.