I have to agree with Mr. Reheat on this. If you don't want to be pushed or are happy with mediocrity then Cathay is NOT the place for you.
If, however, you don't mind knuckling down, doing a bit of work...
A system that marks you on a scale (like Cathay) is bound to come under fire, if you don't put the work in you will be marked down. Just as well pilots have small ego's!!
Live to work or work to live, its up to you, but in my humble opinion an Airline Pilot should think of himself as a Professional. That by definition takes more than the 9 to 5.