PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Chinook - Still Hitting Back 3 (Merged)
View Single Post
Old 10th Aug 2006, 00:03
  #2528 (permalink)  
tucumseh
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: uk
Posts: 3,225
Received 172 Likes on 65 Posts
Walter

Again, while I can’t absolutely discount your theory (on the use of AN/AYD-1 Personal Locator System), for it to be valid would require the AN/ARS-6(V) in the aircraft to have been pre-loaded with the unique crypto ID of the actual AN/PRC-112s borne by the troops on the ground. And unless the Mk2 was already fitted with a broadband UHF homing system (and few a/c were in 94), and the matched antennae feeders could be used by AN/ARS-6(V), then the sudden appearance of two very obvious UHF homing blades on the airframe would be very noticeable. And, to avoid a hefty mod and pretty extensive trials, these pre-existing antennae would have to be already configured such that one was shared with a UHF radio, and the Tx/Rx positioned more or less precisely where the UHF Homer was. This, in addition to the reasons I gave recently, is simply too much to keep hidden all these years. An awful lot of work involving at least four contractors, and in 1993/4 at least seven departments across MoD, must go into such an installation design to reach the stage where one pitches up and plugs ARS-6 in as a role mod.

Sorry mate, it’s technically feasible but in my opinion extremely unlikely. Taken with categorical assurances from people who were there (Aldergrove) that ZD576 wasn’t AYD-1 enabled, I think you have to accept there are easier ways to discredit the verdict. The difficult thing is persuading the MoD to be honourable in the face of factual evidence.
tucumseh is offline