MM didn't mean to infer anyone passing judgement etc, apologies if it sounded that way.
ERAS problem only if what is written is not true. From my experience this is not the case. The S/O's opinion of his performance may differ from the instructor however the observer is usually in a better position to make the assessment & usually has more experience to do so.
Again I'm not trying to be confrontational but there seems to be a perception out there that less than glowing ERAS reports are written to hold S/Os back, that is far from the truth in fact the opposite is closer to the truth.