This argument is getting a bit silly. If we filter out all the noise of the last few posts we get:
jp said in response to Meadowbank:
I hear you,but do not forget that the verdict of the four Lords who volunteered to look at the case was thrown out in a free vote by the whole House.
southbound said:
It rightly questions whether they* agreed with the report or were politically motivated.
* the late influx of peers who came in just for the vote without listening to the debate. Where they were during the debate is not the issue.