Originally Posted by MrBitsy
I do accept it's illegal - just pointing out that all frequencies are published and available to all
, so that could be interpreted by many as a go to listen in.
What about the positive side of listening in - everytime the press print one of the silly "near miss" stories, I have the knowledge to defend the ATC guys to friends and family
RK.
Mr Bitsy.
The frequencies are published in specific documents and indicate the service available on each. Therefore, unless you are participating in that service, it is not a "free for all". Because of the nature of radio waves and the simplex frequencies employed, it is impossible to prevent non-participants monitoring; however, they should realise that they are putting their ears to the keyhole of what is essentially a private exchange. By comparison, how would you view someone putting a telephone tap on an inter-unit landline? Or on your BT telephone line at home?
With respect, you do
not have the knowledge to defend any ATC "guys" in the case of an alleged incident and it is not your place to do so, using, probably wrongly, any information you might have gleaned through illegal monitoring. That is no more sensible or legal than the press "shock horror" stories gained from similar sources. The facts and factors contributing to any incident are usually many and complex and are not apparent merely from one overheard RTF exchange.