I have flown both, and they both have pros/cons
I prefer the Piper, I find it a little more responsive, and the landing is just so much easier in the piper. There are a few extra things to worry about. The piper has 2 fuel tanks, and an electronic fuel pump. Not much of a problem, but just a few extra things to keep an eye on while flying, and the take off/landing procedures have a few more steps
Cessna, I found was very stable, did not have to worry about fuel pumps or changing tanks. Ground visibility is better, as you ain't got a wing below you.
I would spend an hour in each and see how you feel. I think it is an individual thing