you/ the then BALPA membership essentially agreed to BARP under the very misguided illusion that NAPS would be kept safe if you did so.
That may be your take on it BH, but nobody elses. Nobody believed BARPs was some sort of magic wand that would keep NAPS safe. It was a case of nobody believing that a fight to keep NAPS open was a fight we could win. The fact that nobody in any other major company seems to have managed to keep an FSS open to new employees would tend to support that view.