Hmm, I agree with the idea of fewer rules, yes.
But, A and C, I think you may have shot yourself in the foot with the example you use to back up your argument.
Just take a look at the two YES ! two pages on this forum on the subject of club checks and you will see what I am getting at
In this specific case, the reason the thread has gone on so long is because there is a
lack of rules. Nowhere in any written document does the CAA give any guidance on how to log club checks. By simply adding one line into LASORS which specifically allowed logging PICUS for a club check, the CAA could turn this particular question into a 1-line answer with no debate - but they haven't done so, and that is why the question gets asked so frequently, and why the answers run to pages.
FFF
--------------