What you asked for was speculation....
As a fellow ex-A Cat, A2QFI, MG, IRE, TAARI, EWO, Full Flight Test Capt, Examiner, FSO, blah blan blah, I trust you will agree with me that fact is the only consideration.
"Rule books are only paper, they will not cushion impacts between metal and stone"
We don't know the true facts. Neither did Wratten or Day. Everything else was informed hearsay and/or speculation. Certainly not enough to bring the unjust verdict which they did.