NC43 - apparently we both think this individual acted honourably - but neither of us are saluting him beyond that. If he publishes then we can judge on his account at that time. I think it is right that he should be able to - but for sure any discomfiture for the government in his present actions or in a subsequent book will have a knock on effect for those serving. It might be good if clearer and more honest decision taking is made by politicians but equally it can be bad for providing propaganda to the extremists. Is that not a price for democracy?